I spent some time with my buddy Dave in Vegas tonight. We played this tournament at Treasure Island called 'Head Hunters'. It's a $125 buy-in: $50 goes to the prize pool, $50 is put on your head as a bounty, and $25 to the house. With only 17 players tonight, it was a pretty friendly and casual game. Since so much of the buy-in consists of a bounty, it basically prices people in to taking thin gambles in hopes of knocking players out of the tournament.
One of Dave's friends in the tournament, a guy known to as 'O.D.', got some 'What Lodden Thinks' action going.
I am not the best source of information on how this game acquired its name. But the gist of it is that some poker players (I want to say Phil Laak was one of the originators) decided to gamble amongst each other on what poker player Johnny Lodden (who was at their table at the time) thinks the answer to a bunch of random questions are. So the game became known as 'What Lodden Thinks' and has retained that title to this day.
Here is an example of how it works:
I suggested to O.D. that we bet on the number of miles per hour that Dave thinks an elephant is capable of running. So Dave thinks of that number in his head and informs us when he has reached a decision. Then O.D. and I set the market in an auction fashion. One person states a number, and the other person can either say "sold" (thus buying the "under") or counter with a higher number.
So with the elephant example, I started the auction at 4 (miles per hour). O.D. countered with something like 10. I countered with 15. He countered with 25 and I said "sold", thereby making it so that if Dave's number is 24 or less, I win, and if it's 26 or more, O.D. wins.
I think in this particular example, Dave's guess was something like 24. Whatever, it doesn't matter. The point was just to explain how the game was played.
Obviously when you get around a bunch of degenerate gamblers, you can start having a lot of fun with this game. O.D. and I kept it friendly and went $5 per prop on a bunch of random stuff. We probably came up with 25 random propositions over the course of the night. Here are some of the memorable ones:
"How much money does [Bystander A] think [Bystander B] has spent in his lifetime on watches?"
"How many trees does Dave think are on Earth?"
"How many miles does Dave think Michael Phelps has swam in his life?"
"On a scale of 0-100, how will our waiter rate Barack Obama's job performance as President?"
"One in how many people will Dave think get struck by lightning in their lifetime?"
"What is the highest number that Dave thinks a human has ever counted to out loud without ever stopping for more than one minute?"
"How many people does Dave think live in Sarasota, Florida?"
"How many WSOP bracelets does Dave think Phil Hellmuth, Doyle Brunson, and Allen Cunningham will have in their lifetimes combined?"
What makes this game so fun is that the potential is limitless. You can bet $1,000 on how many M&M's your cocktail waitress thinks are in a standard sized package. An interesting part is that it never matters what the real answer is, it only matters what someone thinks the real answer is. This forces you to factor in variables like the intelligence of the person who is thinking of the number. Because you might know full-well that there are probably ~50 M&M's in a package, but if your cocktail waitress partied a little too hard in her early 20s, she might think there are 600.
With $5 on the line, we asked our waiter at the Grand Lux in Venetian what the most number of T-Rex's he thinks have been alive simultaneously on this planet. I think we had set the number somewhere around 14,000. The waiter's response was 5, as in "five". His logic was that "there could never be that many of them because they would all just eat each other." Needless to say, this game can teach you quite a bit about someone's intelligence and/or reasoning abilities.
The funniest one of the night was when O.D. and I bet on how much money a young guy at our table thinks Britney Spears would want in order to sleep with O.D. with a condition being that she knows no one will ever find out she slept with him, let alone accepted money to do so.
After O.D. and I ran the auction from $20,000 all the way up to $800,000 before one of us bought it, the young guy at the table goes, "man you guys are way off. My guess is $45, the cost of four shots of Patron."